First, Second & Third Round Table Conferences

The Round Table Conferences (1930-1932) were a series of discussions organised by the British government to deliberate on India’s constitutional future and political representation. These conferences highlighted the complexities of India’s diverse socio-political landscape and the challenges of achieving consensus on self-rule. This article aims to study in detail the context, proceedings, and outcomes of the First, Second, and Third Round Table Conferences.

About Round Table Conferences

• The Round Table Conferences held between 1930 and 1932, were a series of high-profile discussions organised by the British government to frame a constitutional future for India.
• These conferences became a platform to negotiate between Indian political aspirations and British colonial policies.
• Though significant in bringing diverse Indian voices to the negotiating table, they were marked by deadlocks and disappointments, especially for the Indian National Congress.

The First Round Table Conference (1930-1931)

The First Round Table Conference, held in London between November 1930 and January 1931, was convened without the participation of the Congress, which had launched the Civil Disobedience Movement.

Key Features of First Round Table Conference (1930-1931)

• Delegates included representatives of princely states, minorities (Muslims, Anglo-Indians, Sikhs), and loyalists to the British government.
• Discussions centered on federalism, minority rights, and safeguards for princely states.
• Consensus was reached on dominion status as the ultimate goal and the formation of a federation with princely states.

Outcome of First Round Table Conference (1930-1931)

• The absence of the Congress made the discussions incomplete and unrepresentative of Indian political aspirations.
• The British realised the importance of engaging Congress and Gandhi in subsequent talks.

The Second Round Table Conference (1931)

• Mahatma Gandhi, along with Sarojini Naidu, was the sole Congress representative at the Second Round Table Conference, which was held from September to December 1931. Gandhi’s participation followed the Gandhi-Irwin Pact of March 1931.

Key Features of Second Round Table Conference (1931)

• Gandhi argued for full self-government and claimed that Congress represented 85% of Indians, but British officials and minority representatives rejected this claim.
• The conference saw intense debates over minority rights, with Muslims, Anglo-Indians, Christians, and Depressed Classes demanding separate electorates, culminating in the Minorities’ Pact.
• Right-wing British politicians, led by Winston Churchill, opposed negotiations on an equal footing with Congress.

Outcome of Second Round Table Conference (1931)

• The conference ended in deadlock, with Gandhi returning to India frustrated.
• The British rejected Gandhi’s demand for self-government, and political unrest resumed in India, leading to the second phase of the Civil Disobedience Movement.

The Third Round Table Conference (1932)

The Third Round Table Conference, held from November to December 1932, was largely insignificant due to Congress’s boycott and lack of notable Indian leaders.

Key Features of Third Round Table Conference (1932)

• Discussions focused on the implementation of previous agreements and constitutional reforms.
• Princely states and minority groups reaffirmed their demands but lacked comprehensive representation.

Outcome of Third Round Table Conference (1932)

• The conference failed to make meaningful progress, further delaying constitutional reforms and strengthening Indian opposition to colonial policies.

Significance of Round Table Conferences

• These conferences highlighted the deep divisions between various Indian groups and the British government.
• The failure to reconcile minority and nationalist demands strengthened British policies of “divide and rule.”
• The constitutional deliberations laid the groundwork for the Government of India Act of 1935, which introduced limited provincial autonomy but fell short of Indian aspirations for self-rule.

Conclusion

In conclusion, though an ambitious attempt at dialogue, the Round Table Conferences underscored the challenges of negotiating India’s future under colonial rule. They also exposed the limitations of British willingness to accommodate Indian demands, fueling the momentum for complete independence.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

GS - 1