Reservation Debate within Transgender Community

Syllabus: GS1/Society, GS2/Governance

Context

  • National Commission for Scheduled Castes (NCSC) has taken cognisance of atrocity complaint against Uttar Pradesh’s Transgender Welfare Board Member, a strong proponent of vertical reservation.

About

  • Under the Vertical reservations all trans people would qualify for reservation, irrespective of their socio-economic category.
  • Many trans activists across the country have stressed that horizontal reservations are the need of the hour as vertical quotas ignore the layered nature of discrimination trans people from marginalized castes face. 
AspectHorizontal ReservationVertical Reservation
DefinitionReservation for a specific group within a larger category.Reservation for specific categories such as caste, class, etc.
Target GroupBeneficiaries within the group or class of a larger category (e.g., disabled people within SC).Entire categories or classes 
ExampleReservation for women within SC or OBC groups.Reservation for SC, ST, and OBC categories in general.
SignificanceUsed to address sub-categories within a reserved category.Used to allocate a percentage of seats to specific castes.

Supreme Court’s 2014 Judgement

  • In 2014, the Supreme Court directed governments to provide reservation to trans people in government jobs and education.
    • Since then the demand for quotas from the community has only grown. 
  • Ambiguity: There is an ambiguity in the Supreme Court’s direction, which called for transgender people to be treated as socially and educationally backward classes of citizens.
    • It has divided opinion within the transgender community on what kind of reservations should be provided.  
    • This also raises the question that there are transgender people in all caste categories. How is bunching them up as OBCs serving the purpose of equality? 
Queer community
– The queer community is an inclusive and diverse group of people who identify as lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, questioning, intersex, asexual, or any other sexual orientation, gender identity, or expression that falls outside of societal norms. 

Legal Rights to Transgenders in India

  • Supreme Court’s NALSA Judgment (2014): The National Legal Services Authority v. Union of India (NALSA) case was a landmark judgment where the Supreme Court of India recognized transgender individuals as a third gender.
    • This judgment granted them legal recognition, fundamental rights, and a constitutional right to live with dignity.
    • Recognising third gender persons as a “socially and educationally backward class of citizens”, entitled to reservations in educational institutions and public employment.
  • Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019: This law was passed to safeguard the rights of transgender people in India. It includes provisions for:
    • Self-identification: Transgender individuals have the right to self-identify their gender, and they can apply for a certificate that recognizes their gender identity as per their choice (male, female, or transgender).
    • Prohibition of Discrimination: Discrimination against transgender people in areas like education, employment, healthcare, and public services is illegal.
    • Establishment of National and State Transgender Welfare Boards: These boards are set up to address issues related to transgender people.
  • Transgender Bill (2021): Although the 2019 Act laid a foundation, the 2021 amendments were proposed to strengthen provisions related to their legal recognition and welfare, but debates continue on whether it provides enough protection or falls short in certain areas.

Challenges

  • Despite the legal protections, transgender individuals face widespread social stigma and discrimination.
  • Violence and harassment in public spaces.
  • Limited access to education and employment.
  • Challenges in accessing healthcare and legal recognition.
  • Economic and social exclusion often forces transgender people into marginalized roles, such as begging or sex work.

Way Ahead

  • While there has been significant progress in advancing LGBTQ+ rights and reducing discrimination, there are still many challenges to address. 
  • Continued advocacy, education, and policy change are necessary to ensure full equality and acceptance for the LGBTQ+ community worldwide.

Source: TH

 

Other News of the Day

Syllabus: GS1/Geography Context Recently, the United States has experienced one of the most severe winter storms in over a decade, largely attributed to the polar vortex. About the Polar Vortex It is a large area of low-pressure and cold air that swirls around the Earth’s polar regions.  It exists in two forms: Tropospheric polar vortex,...
Read More

Syllabus: GS1/ Geography Context  Recently a strong earthquake with a magnitude of 7.1 struck in western China near Nepal. About The epicenter of the earthquake was identified in Tingry County in the Shigatse region of Tibet, a significant location as it serves as a ‘gateway’ to Mount Everest.  The earthquake’s mainshock likely occurred within the...
Read More

Syllabus: GS2/ Governance In News The Ministry of Road Transport and Highways (MoRTH) has recently unveiled a nationwide cashless treatment initiative aimed at providing essential aid to victims of road accidents. Background The scheme builds on a pilot program launched on March 14, 2024 which has since been expanded to include Assam, Punjab, Haryana, and...
Read More

Syllabus: GS2/ Polity and Governance Context The demands to repeal Sections 33 and 81 of the Delhi Land Reforms Act of 1954 resurfaced after allegations that the Union government failed to fulfill its promise. Delhi Land Reforms Act, 1954 The Delhi Land Reforms Act, 1954 was enacted to modify the Zamindari System and unify the...
Read More

Syllabus :GS2/IR In Context The meeting took place in Dubai, marking the highest-level engagement between India and the Taliban since the latter’s takeover of Afghanistan in 2021. India has not formally recognized the Taliban administration but it maintains a small mission in Kabul for trade, aid, and medical support, alongside ongoing humanitarian assistance. Key Outcomes...
Read More

Syllabus: GS3/Infrastructure, Disaster Management Context The Supreme Court seeks Centre’s response on Mullaperiyar dam safety and questions the delay in forming an expert committee under the Dam Safety Act of 2021. Mullaperiyar dam is built on the Periyar River in Kerala. It is a 130-year-old year old dam. People in Kerala living downstream Mullaperiyar dam...
Read More

Soapstone Mining Syllabus: GS1/ Geography, GS2/ Governance Context Uttarakhand High Court has ordered an immediate stop to mining operations in Bageshwar district after illegal activities led to cracks in houses and hills. What is Soapstone? Soapstone is a metamorphic rock composed mainly of talc, a naturally occurring mineral. It is widely used for; Construction and...
Read More