Syllabus: GS2/Polity and Governance
Context
- In a significant move aimed at enhancing the efficiency of arbitration proceedings in India, the Department of Legal Affairs in the Union Law Ministry has introduced a Draft Arbitration and Conciliation (Amendment) Bill, 2024 to amend the Arbitration and Conciliation Act.
Draft Arbitration and Conciliation (Amendment) Bill, 2024
- It proposes several significant amendments to the existing Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
- The primary objective is to boost institutional arbitration, reduce court intervention, and ensure the timely conclusion of arbitration proceedings.
| Arbitration – It is a form of alternative dispute resolution where the parties involved in a dispute agree to submit their conflict to one or more arbitrators. – These arbitrators are neutral third parties who review the evidence, hear arguments, and then make a binding decision on the matter. – The process is less formal than a court trial and is often faster and more flexible. Arbitration is commonly used in commercial disputes and is governed by the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 in India. Conciliation – It is a voluntary process where a neutral third party, known as the conciliator, helps the disputing parties to reach a mutually acceptable agreement. – Unlike arbitration, the conciliator does not have the authority to impose a decision. Instead, they facilitate communication and negotiation between the parties to help them resolve their differences. – Conciliation is often used in labour disputes and other situations where maintaining a relationship between the parties is important. |
Key Highlights of the Draft Bill
- Emergency Arbitration: One of the most notable provisions in the draft bill is the introduction of emergency arbitration.
- It allows for the appointment of an emergency arbitrator to grant interim measures before the constitution of the arbitral tribunal. It is expected to provide swift relief in urgent situations, aligning Indian arbitration practices with international standards.
- Promotion of Institutional Arbitration: The draft bill emphasises the promotion of institutional arbitration over ad-hoc arrangements.
- By encouraging the use of established arbitration institutions, the bill aims to enhance the efficiency and reliability of arbitration proceedings.
- Arbitration Council of India (ACI): The bill proposes empowering the Arbitration Council of India to create model rules of procedure for arbitral proceedings and recognize arbitral institutions.
- It is intended to standardise practices and improve the overall quality of arbitration in India.
- Video Conferencing: Recognising the advancements in technology and the need for flexibility, the draft bill includes provisions for conducting arbitration proceedings via video conferencing.
- It is expected to make arbitration more accessible and reduce logistical challenges.
- Appellate Arbitral Tribunal: To handle applications against arbitral awards, the bill proposes the establishment of an Appellate Arbitral Tribunal.
- It aims to streamline the appeals process and reduce the burden on courts.
- Omission of Conciliation Provisions: The draft bill proposes omitting the conciliation provisions from the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, as these have been incorporated into the Mediation Act, 2023.
- Consequently, the amended act will be renamed the Arbitration Act, 1996.
- Expert Committee Recommendations: The draft bill incorporates recommendations from an expert committee led by former law secretary and former Lok Sabha Secretary General T K Vishwanathan.
- It emphasised the need for reforms to make arbitration more effective and less reliant on judicial intervention.
Key Issues and Concerns
- Legal Recognition: Not all jurisdictions recognise the concept of emergency arbitration.
- Ensuring that the awards or orders issued by emergency arbitrators are enforceable can be a significant hurdle.
- Institutional Support: Effective emergency arbitration requires robust support from arbitration institutions.
- It includes having clear rules, a roster of qualified emergency arbitrators, and efficient administrative processes.
- Time Constraints: Emergency arbitration is designed to provide swift relief, often within days.
- It can put immense pressure on both the arbitrator and the parties involved to present and consider evidence quickly, which might compromise the thoroughness of the process.
- Costs: The expedited nature of emergency arbitration can lead to higher costs due to the need for rapid action and potentially more intensive use of resources.
- Awareness and Acceptance: Parties may be unfamiliar with or sceptical about the emergency arbitration process.
- Building trust and understanding among users is crucial for its successful implementation.
- Interim Measures: The effectiveness of emergency arbitration depends on the ability to grant and enforce interim measures.
- It can be challenging if the measures require actions in multiple jurisdictions or if local courts are not supportive.
Implications for the Arbitration Landscape
- The proposed amendments are expected to significantly impact the arbitration landscape in India. By introducing emergency arbitration and promoting institutional arbitration, the bill aims to make arbitration a more efficient and reliable method of dispute resolution.
- By providing a mechanism for urgent interim relief, it aligns Indian arbitration practices with international standards, potentially increasing the confidence of foreign investors and parties in the Indian arbitration system.
- It could lead to a reduction in the backlog of cases in Indian courts and enhance the overall ease of doing business in the country.
Conclusion
- The Draft Arbitration and Conciliation (Amendment) Bill, 2024, represents a significant step towards modernising and improving the arbitration framework in India.
- By introducing emergency arbitration and promoting institutional arbitration, the government aims to make arbitration a more efficient and reliable method of dispute resolution.
- By addressing key issues and incorporating international best practices, the government aims to make arbitration a more attractive and efficient dispute resolution mechanism.
Previous article
Election Expenditure in India
Next article
UK Phase-Out Coal Power Plant